Cooking TipsIngredient SwapsHealth

Swap This for Canola: 12 Oil Substitutes for Baking, Frying and Dressings

UUnknown

2026-02-26

11 min read

Practical, hands-on guide to 12 canola oil substitutes for baking, frying and dressings with smoke points, flavour and health notes.

Fed up with canola oil or need an urgent swap? Here’s the practical guide that saves recipes — and your dinner

If you’ve ever stood at the kitchen counter mid-recipe wondering “what can I use instead of canola oil?”, this hands-on guide is for you. Whether canola is out of stock, you want a flavour change, or you’re adjusting for smoke point and health, I’ll walk you through 12 reliable canola substitutes and exactly how to use them for baking, frying and dressings.

Tip up front: most oil swaps are 1:1 by volume, but the real decisions are about flavour, smoke point and how the oil behaves in the recipe. Read the quick-use maps below, then deep-dive into each substitute with practical notes and 2026 trends that influence availability and price in the UK.

Quick substitute map — best swaps by cooking context

Here’s a quick cheat-sheet: pick the swap by what you’re cooking.

Baking (neutral flavour): sunflower (refined), light olive oil, grapeseed, refined avocado.
Roasting & high-heat frying: refined avocado, high-oleic sunflower, refined peanut, ghee/clarified butter.
Pan-frying & sautés: light olive oil, refined avocado, vegetable oil blends.
Deep-frying: refined peanut, high-oleic sunflower, refined avocado or ghee.
Dressings & cold sauces: extra-virgin olive oil, walnut oil, sesame oil (for Asian flavours), flaxseed oil (cold only).

The 12 canola oil substitutes — smoke point, flavour & practical notes

Each entry lists a typical smoke point (approximate — always check the bottle), flavour character, best uses and health note. Use these to choose confidently.

1. Light / Refined Olive Oil

Smoke point: ~220–240°C. Flavour: mild, olive notes but far less grassy than extra virgin.

Best for: pan-frying, roasting, baking when you want a subtle flavour.
Swap ratio: 1:1 for canola.
Health note: rich in monounsaturated fats (good for heart health). A versatile, easy-to-find UK supermarket staple.

2. Extra-Virgin Olive Oil (EVOO)

Smoke point: ~180–210°C (lower than refined). Flavour: robust, peppery or fruity.

Best for: dressings, finishing oil, low-to-medium-heat pan cooking and olive-oil cakes where the flavour is desired.
Swap ratio: 1:1 in dressings and many baked goods where olive flavour complements ingredients (carrot cake, courgette bread). For high-heat frying, avoid EVOO or use a refined oil instead.
Health note: excellent source of monounsaturates and polyphenols; a top healthy swap for cold uses.

3. Refined Avocado Oil

Smoke point: ~250–270°C. Flavour: neutral to lightly buttery.

Best for: searing, deep and shallow frying, roasting, and when you want a neutral high-heat oil.
Swap ratio: 1:1 for canola.
Health note: high in monounsaturated fats; more expensive but prized for performance.

4. Virgin (Cold-Pressed) Avocado Oil

Smoke point: ~190–200°C (lower than refined). Flavour: green, grassy avocado notes.

Best for: dressings, finishing, low-heat sautés where avocado flavour is welcome.
Swap ratio: 1:1, but consider flavour impact.
Health note: good for cold uses and medium heat; in 2025–26 demand increased in UK shops for cold-pressed oils.

5. High-Oleic Sunflower Oil

Smoke point: ~230–246°C. Flavour: neutral.

Best for: deep frying, roasting, baking — a near-perfect neutral substitute for canola.
Swap ratio: 1:1.
Health note: bred to be higher in monounsaturated fats than standard sunflower, which reduces concerns about omega-6 overload. This variety has surged in availability across UK retailers in 2025–26.

6. Regular Sunflower or Vegetable Oil

Smoke point: ~220–230°C. Flavour: neutral.

Best for: everyday cooking, baking and frying. Cheap and widely available.
Swap ratio: 1:1.
Health note: higher in polyunsaturated fats; rotate with monounsaturated oils to balance omega ratios.

7. Grapeseed Oil

Smoke point: ~200–230°C. Flavour: very neutral.

Best for: baking, dressings (neutral base), medium-high heat frying.
Swap ratio: 1:1.
Health note: light and neutral but higher in polyunsaturates; stable for many kitchen tasks but keep refrigerated after opening if using for dressings infrequently.

8. Refined Peanut Oil

Smoke point: ~225–235°C. Flavour: faint nutty aroma when refined; stronger when unrefined.

Best for: deep-frying, high-heat wok cooking and anything needing a slight nutty lift.
Swap ratio: 1:1.
Health note: good heat tolerance. Avoid if there are nut allergies in your household or when serving guests with unknown allergies.

9. Coconut Oil (Refined & Virgin)

Smoke point: refined ~204°C; virgin ~175–190°C. Flavour: coconutty in virgin, neutral in refined.

Best for: baking (brownies, tropical cakes), medium-heat frying and recipes that tolerate coconut flavour. Avoid in dressings where it will solidify at room temperature.
Swap ratio: 1:1 for oil; if substituting for butter, remember butter has water so adjust — see baking tips below.
Health note: high in saturated fat. Use deliberately for texture/flavour rather than as a straight health swap.

10. Ghee / Clarified Butter

Smoke point: ~230–250°C. Flavour: buttery, toasty.

Best for: high-heat frying, roasting and when you want buttery flavour without milk solids burning.
Swap ratio: 1:1 by volume as a cooking oil. For baking, remember 1 cup butter ≈ ¾ cup oil; ghee acts more like butter in flavour and function.
Health note: more saturated fat than most oils, but excellent for flavour and high-heat stability.

11. Sesame Oil (Refined & Toasted)

Smoke point: refined ~210°C; toasted ~160–175°C. Flavour: toasted sesame is intensely nutty; refined is much milder.

Best for: dressings, marinades, finishing or Asian-style cooking. Use toasted sesame sparingly — a teaspoon or two can flavour a whole dish.
Swap ratio: 1:1 for canola when using refined; toasted is typically used as a finishing oil, not a 1:1 bulk swap.
Health note: great source of flavour; not ideal for high-heat unless refined.

12. Walnut Oil (and Other Nut Oils / Flaxseed Oil for Cold Use)

Smoke point: walnut ~160–200°C (low). Flaxseed oil ~107°C (very low). Flavour: rich, nutty and delicate.

Best for: vinaigrettes, finishing, drizzle on cooked vegetables, cold sauces. Do not use flaxseed oil for frying — it oxidises quickly and tastes bitter when heated.
Swap ratio: 1:1 in dressings and cold applications. Use sparingly for flavour intensity.
Health note: walnut and flax oils are high in omega‑3s (good) but unstable at heat — keep in the fridge and use within weeks.

Best practice: Choose the oil based on heat and flavour, not just price. A neutral, high‑smoke oil keeps textures right; a flavoured oil can transform a dish.

Baking swaps — structure, moisture and flavour explained

Baking is where swaps feel fiddle‑y, because oil affects crumb, moisture and aeration. Here’s the good news: most quick breads, muffins and sponges that use canola can swap straight to a neutral oil 1:1 (sunflower, light olive, grapeseed, refined avocado).

When you can swap 1:1

Muffins, loaf cakes, brownies and quickbreads made using an oil method: use 1:1 neutral oil swap.
Recipes that call for “vegetable oil” are explicitly designed for neutral swaps.

When to adjust

Recipes relying on creamed butter for aeration (traditional Victoria sponge): don’t simply swap for oil. If you want less butter, replace part of the butter with oil (e.g., use 50% butter + 50% oil by fat weight) and accept a denser crumb.
Substituting butter for oil: use ¾ cup oil for every 1 cup melted butter — butter contains ~20% water so the fat volumes differ.
Using coconut oil: melt first and cool slightly; expect a firmer texture at cool room temperatures because coconut solidifies.

Flavor-forward baking ideas

Olive oil in olive-oil cake or lemon drizzle gives a fruity lift.
Walnut oil in an iced coffee cake makes an autumnal profile — use cold-only nut oils for flavour.

Frying & high heat — safety and performance

High heat demands high smoke points. When oil reaches smoke point it breaks down, develops off-flavours and creates harmful compounds. For deep frying or searing:

Choose refined avocado, refined peanut, high-oleic sunflower or ghee.
Keep oil temperature steady; use a thermometer and don’t crowd the pan.
Filter and store frying oil if you’ll reuse it; discard if it smells rancid or develops a dark colour.

Dressings, mayonnaise & cold sauces — flavour first

For cold applications, flavour and cold-stability are your priorities:

Extra-virgin olive oil is the classic choice for vinaigrettes and mayonnaise — use for Mediterranean flavours.
For neutral-flavoured mayo or aioli, use light olive, sunflower or grapeseed oil for a clean taste and stable emulsion.
Use walnut oil, sesame or flaxseed as secondary oils — add a tablespoon to a larger neutral-oil base to impart distinctive character.
Flaxseed oil must be refrigerated and is only for cold use.

Allergy, sustainability and health notes — 2026 context

Two practical trends shaped the oil market going into 2026:

Trade and availability: Following January 2026 tariff relief between Canada and China, canola shipments and prices have stabilised; however, UK shoppers are still seeing strong competition between olive, sunflower and avocado oil ranges. That means more choices — and more need to pick the right oil for the job.
Product innovation: High-oleic sunflower varieties and clearer provenance labelling grew in 2025–26. Retailers now publish intended use (frying vs finishing) and sometimes smoke points on bottles — use that info.

Health pointers:

Rotate oils. Use monounsaturated-rich oils (olive, avocado) frequently and balance polyunsaturates with antioxidants (vitamin E).
Limit overuse of oils high in saturated fat (coconut, ghee) and keep serving sizes sensible.
Be conscious of omega‑6 (linoleic acid) intake from regular sunflower and some seed oils; if you consume lots of processed foods you may want to increase monounsaturated choices.

Practical kitchen cheats & troubleshooting

Swapping in a hurry

Out of canola for a roast? Use light olive or high-oleic sunflower at 1:1.
Need a neutral frying oil? Reach for refined avocado or refined peanut (allergy check first).
Out of oil for a salad dressing? Use EVOO for flavour or grapeseed for a neutral base.

My cake is dense after swapping to oil — why?

Likely you swapped for a recipe that depends on creamed butter for aeration. Use an oil-designed recipe next time, or use part butter and part oil. For lighter cakes with oil, whisk eggs well to add air.

My dressing separated — how to save it?

Bring the oil and vinegar to the same temperature before emulsifying, or add mustard as an emulsifier. Use a hand blender for a stable mayo with neutral oil.

Shopping checklist — what to look for in 2026

Labelled smoke point or “best for” usage on the bottle.
“High-oleic” on sunflower oil for better stability.
Cold-pressed vs refined: choose cold-pressed for dressings and refined for high heat.
Look at origin and supply notes if sustainability matters — some retailers list carbon or farming practices.

Quick substitution summary (one-line cheat sheet)

Need neutral for baking or frying: high-oleic sunflower, grapeseed, refined avocado.
Need flavourful for dressings: extra‑virgin olive, walnut, toasted sesame.
Need high-heat performance: refined avocado, refined peanut, ghee.
Want a healthier routine: rotate olive, avocado and high-oleic sunflower across meals.

Final tips and a 2026 prediction

As consumers in the UK, we’re seeing more specific oil labelling and a wider availability of high-oleic sunflower and avocado options thanks to global market shifts in late 2025 and early 2026. That makes choosing the right oil easier — but it also means home cooks should pick oils based on usage rather than marketing. Keep neutral, high-smoke oils for high heat, reserve extra-virgin and nut oils for cold or finishing uses, and always store delicate oils in a cool, dark place (fridge for flax and walnut).

Actionable takeaways

For most recipes, swap canola 1:1 with refined sunflower or light olive oil.
Choose refined avocado or high‑oleic sunflower for high heat and deep frying.
Use extra‑virgin olive or walnut oil for dressings and finishing touches.
When baking, match the original method: if the recipe creams butter, don’t simply swap all the butter for oil without expecting texture changes.
Store delicate oils chilled and use within weeks to avoid rancidity.

Try this experiment tonight

Swap canola for refined avocado in a roast chicken (1:1) and for extra-virgin olive oil in a lemon vinaigrette. Notice the difference in crispness and flavour — small swaps like these are the fastest way to learn how oils change dishes.

Want recipes that use these swaps? We test and publish oil-specific recipes and substitution notes every month. Bookmark our recipes page and sign up for email updates to get tested swaps and cook-with-confidence tips straight to your inbox.

Unknown

Contributor

Senior editor and content strategist. Writing about technology, design, and the future of digital media. Follow along for deep dives into the industry's moving parts.